Lost Green Card: Replace? Renew? What is the Right Form?

fickeymartinez • October 5, 2019

When someone loses a Green Card, the first instinct is to pay for a replacement. However, that can actually be the wrong option or a choice that does not meet your needs. The loss could occur when you lose your purse or wallet, but often times it can also be from never receiving the card in the mail. In a nutshell, a “Green Card lost situation” can be broken into different types:

  1. A Conditional Green Card, which expires within 2 years
  2. A 10-year Green Card, which DOES have more than 6 months remaining on it
  3. A 10-year Green Card, which DOES NOT have more than 6 months remaining on it
  4. A Green Card that does not have an expiration date
  5. I never received a Green Card from USCIS, but I do have a 1-year Temporary Green Card Proof in my Passport
  6. I never received a Green Card from USCIS after an Adjustment of Status Filing

As you can see, there are many types of Green Card “Lose,” and each scenario has a differing outcome. But, before we evaluate the ideal outcomes, let us see the three filing options:

  • I-90 – Replace/Renew a Green Card
  • I-751 – Remove Conditions on a Conditional Green Card
  • N-400 – Green Card Holder has held the Green Card long enough to qualify for Naturalization as a US Citizen, and meets all other eligibility requirements.

Let us explain the possible ideal outcomes in the order stated above, from 1 to 6.

A Conditional Green Card, which expires within 2 years

A Conditional Green Card is a Green Card based on Marriage less than 2-years old at the time of the Immigrant Interview. Since Marriage is less than 2 years, the Green Card is only valid for 2 years. Believe it or not, Conditional Green Card Holders frequently believe the I-90 is the proper form and usually wastes $540 in filing the I-90 form. The truth is, everything depends on:

  • First, whether the Green Card Holder is still married; and, if not married, whether the Green Card Holder qualifies for a Waiver of the I-751.
  • Second, how close has the loss occurred to the green card’s expiration date.

(If still married, and would need the I-751 Joint Filing at the end of month 21 of the Green Card) If a Conditional Lawful Permanent Resident loses the card between Month 0 to 21, the I-90 may be filed, but may never produce a Green Card since the I-90 filing can take 1 to 2 years to process. If the Card expires within 90 days of the loss, the I-751 would actually provide an 18-month extension, and an INFOPASS would permit the Green Card Holder to acquire an I-551 Stamp in the Foreign Passport for free. This is a situation whether an I-751 might be better than an I-90, but it really does depend on when the loss occurs, the close to the expiration, the better the I-751 looks.

Note: The I-751 Joint Married Filing can only be filed 90 days before the expiration of the Green Card.

(If qualified for an I-751 Waiver Filing) If a Conditional Resident loses the green card at any time during the two year period, the I-751 waiver of the married joint I-751 Filing Requirement may be best. I-751 Waiver filings would have to occur eventually, and they permit the green card holder to directly apply for a “removal of conditions” to the 10-year green card. An I-90 in this situation would actually be bad and delay the immigrant from ever receiving a green card.

If you find yourself in this situation, please contact our law office to set up a consultation.

Please see our I-751 Blog Section, convenient link provided here: https://www.fickeymartinezlaw.com/category/immigration/i-751-removal-of-conditions/

A 10-year Green Card, which DOES have more than 6 months remaining on it

If a Green Card Holder has more than 6-months remaining on the Green Card that was lost, it would be more economical to file the N-400, versus the I-90, assuming all other eligibility requirements for the N-400 exist. Apart from the economical reason, the N-400 generally processes quicker than the I-90. If the filing is quicker and more economical, it can be better to do the N-400 versus the I-90. Contacting a local Immigration Attorney might be helpful.

A 10-year Green Card, which DOES NOT have more than 6 months remaining on it

Under USCIS National Policy, if a Green Card has less than 6 months remaining on it, the Green Card Holder should apply for the I-90. However, like in the above section, if the local USCIS Field Office permits the N-400 even if filed within 6 months of expiration or after the green card expired, the N-400 may be more beneficial than the I-90. Contacting a local Immigration Attorney might be helpful.

A Green Card that does not have an expiration date

This type of green card, the kind that is so old it does not have an expiration date (I-151 Version or I-551 Version), it may be possible to do the I-90 now 10 to 20 years overdue, or the local USCIS Field Office may permit the N-400 to be filed. Contacting a local Immigration Attorney might be helpful.

I never received a Green Card from USCIS, but I do have a 1-year Temporary Green Card Proof in my Passport

Sadly, this issue is very common. USCIS should first receive an E-request to establish the status of the Green Card delivery. If the Online Case Status for the Green Card states it was undeliverable or delivered (but the card never entered your mailbox), the Green Card Holder should contact USCIS IMMEDIATELY and file a complaint at USPS IMMEDIATELY.

If the E-request cannot quickly resolve the issue, an I-90 (free filing) may be required to notify USCIS of their error. Otherwise, the Immigrant may be without a Green Card or Temporary Green Card between month 13 and month 21, waiting to file for the I-751. Again, the I-90 can take 1 to 2 years to process, and it is usually denied since soon the I-751 would be required to be filed. Contacting a local Immigration Attorney might be helpful to figure out the best course of action.

I never received a Green Card from USCIS after an Adjustment of Status Filing

Again, this is a very sad experience, yet very common. Contact USCIS Immediately, and if the calls lead to nothing, try your best to schedule an INFOPASS Appointment with a USCIS Officer to inquiry what happened to the Green Card you thoroughly paid for. Speed in resolving this issue is generally the best action one can perform. The quicker you inquire and try to hunt down the missing green card, the high chance of success you would have. If Inquiry and INFOPASS do not work, filing an I-90 ASAP with the USPS Service Request stating the delivery error (if any) may be successful. The difference in this situation from the above situation is that Consular Processing provides a Visa and Temporary 1-year proof of Lawful Permanent Residence, whereas Adjustment of Status places NOTHING to prove status in your hands.

Should I file a Complaint at USPS if I never Received the Green Card, but it was marked as delivered by USPS?

Yes, if USPS says that the mail was delivered, USCIS will rely on that notice. Filing a complaint is your record of the USPS Error.

 

About Our Immigration Law Firm

We are a North Carolina Based Law Firm that focuses on Immigration Law. Although our offices are in Eastern North Carolina, many of our clients are found around the nation and around the world. Our Immigration Attorney uses online resources to better perform our service. We can meet you via Video Call, by Phone, or at one of our offices located in:

  • Greenville, NC
  • Fayetteville, NC
  • Jacksonville, NC
  • Morehead City, NC

Thank you for reading this blog post!!!

 

More Blog Posts:

 

 

Disclaimer:  This Blog is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 29, 2025
The I-864 is a Sponsorship Form from USCIS that is used in nearly all Family-based Immigration. This Blog Post will address how SSI and SSDI is assessed in this process. SSI (Supplemental Security Income) provides financial assistance to older adults and persons with disabilities (regardless of age) with very limited income and resources. SSI is […] The post I-864 Sponsorship: How is SSI and SSDI Assessed? appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 28, 2025
The I-864 Form (Affidavit of Support) allows the US Government to assess someone’s financial capability to support a sponsored person, whether they are a spouse, parent, child, sibling, and even friend. The I-864 primarily assesses two areas of someone’s financials: Annual Income, derived from Paystubs / Pay Checks Adjusted Gross Income taken from the most […] The post I-864 Asset Calculations appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 27, 2025
This article will cover our office's opinions on the numerous Mobile Immigration Case Tracking Apps, as well as the inaccuracies that arise: Lawfully USCISCaseTracker US Immigration Case Tracker MigraConnect For starters, it is commendable to stay "current" on any immigration filing. Everyone should know what the current status of an immigration filing is. However, the source of information is important. The Federal Government is not "up-to-date" on the Mobile App scene, but most immigration agencies do offer "online case statuses" as well as "processing time estimators." For USCIS, the MYCASE Online Account ( https://myaccount.uscis.gov/sign-in ) should be the primary source of case information. For NVC, the CEAC Online Account ( https://ceac.state.gov/IV/Login.aspx ) should be the primary source of document-uploading, correspondence. For Consular Processing, the specific Embassy or Consulate should be utilized: https://ais.usvisa-info.com/ https://www.ustraveldocs.com/ The third-party mobiles apps are great at providing the "current online status," that information is readily available online at the following agencies: USCIS: https://egov.uscis.gov/ NVC Pre-Documentarily Qualified Status: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/immigrate/nvc-timeframes.html NVC Post-Documentarily Qualified Status: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/visa-information-resources/iv-wait-times.html Embassy/Consulate: https://ceac.state.gov/ceacstattracker/status.aspx Where the mobile apps start to have inaccuracies and mis-information is with regard to the following: Estimated case processing time tends to be 100% inaccurate 3rd-party apps fail to show official USCIS or NVC correspondence, which could delay a filing or lead to a denial Confuse an immigrant beneficiary as to the current phase of the immigration process. When is a Mobile App a good thing? It is a helpful tool for an immigrant that is abroad. It allows the immigrant to receive updates. However, most use the app during the USCIS processing of the I-130, and it is more beneficial to just sign up for a USCIS account and elect for Email updates: https://egov.uscis.gov/ (Only the USCIS Receipt Number is required and anyone or multiple people can sign up for such notification services). Why is the Mobile App inaccurate with the USCIS processing time estimate? The App is inaccurate as the estimator requires the category type and location of processing. If you place the incorrect information, the mobile app would be off. Additionally, USCIS provides a "rough estimate" that occurs for 80% of the cases. USCIS may move quicker or slower depending on the specific case history, USCIS Officer assignment, and the Country of Origin. So, if a mobile app ways an estimated processing time is: 5 months, that should be taken with a grain of salt. USCIS is generally slow with Consular Processing, and a little quicker with Adjustment of Status. Disclaimer: This Blog is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 22, 2025
The ADIT Stamp is a temporary proof of the I-551 Green Card that is an acceptable form of a lawful permanent resident card that can be used for: Domestic and international travel DMV SSA Employment purposes Need of a government-issued ID The ADIT Stamp can be placed in 1 of 3 locations: As a sticker on the back side of a fairly current/recently-expired I-551 Green Card As a Stamp in an unexpired foreign passport AS a Stamp on an I-94 card The ADIT Stamp may be a byproduct of the following Immigration forms: I-90 for a Green Card renewal or replacement after loss/theft I-751 for Removal of Conditions N-400 for Naturalization The document can be a "stamp" and a close look of the stamp is as follows:
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 14, 2025
This article will cover the Old Versions of the Green Cards and how they encounter issues with the DMV when attempting to renew a Driver's License as well as with SSA when attempting to acquire Medicaid, SSD, or SSI. The I-151 Green Card: The former Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) issued Form I-151 (Alien Registration Receipt Card), commonly called a “green card,” to aliens from: July 1946 to 1978. The I-151 Green Card never had an expiration date printed on the card, which has led many to believe their documentation was up-to-date. Even in 2025, I-151 Green Card holders never knew their Green Card had actually expired by law on March 20, 1996 . I-151 card holders experience issues with the DMV, especially after the Real ID Requirements of May 2025, due to the INS records not being easily accessible in current government system, as the INS agency ended in 2003 and was replaced by the agency: USCIS. Additionally, due to I-151 Card Holder's ages, they have either been receiving SSI and Medicaid for many years, or will be starting very soon. For example, if an I-151 Green Card holder received their I-151 Card in 1970 at the age of 10, they would be turning 65 in 2025. According to SSA: Form I-151 is not a valid immigration document. The card lacks security features and presents more opportunities for alteration and fraud than the immigration documents currently being issued. From 1992 through 1996, the former Immigration and Naturalization Service conducted a “Green Card Replacement” project to replace the I-151 cards in circulation. Although the card is not a valid immigration document, the person may still retain lawful permanent status. (Source: https://secure.ssa.gov/poms.nsf/lnx/0200303400) I-151 Card Holders are recommended, depending on their given situation, to either apply for an I-90 Green Card renewal or apply for US Citizenship with the N-400. The I-551 Green Card that didn't expire: The I-551 Green Card is the "current version" of the Lawful Permanent Resident Card. However, there is a lot of confusion on whether the cards with “no expiration date” are still valid. Some government agencies may refer to this un-expiring I-551 as the: ORIGINAL I-551 Whereas, the expiring I-551 may be reviewed to as the: REVISED I-551 The I-551 Green Cards issued between: 1977 and August 1989 have no expiration date, but ARE STILL a valid and acceptable Green Card. However, not every US Agency will acknowledge the old version of the I-551 Green Card since it lacks an expiration date, and a way for the agency to confirm current legal immigration status from when the card was issued in 1977 to 1989. For the DMV, the unexpiring I-551 Green Card may or may not be accepted. A lot has to deal with name changes over the years and whether the file is accessible in current government systems. For SSA, the old or original I-551 is generally accepted as identity is normally compared against a lifelong history of SSA Contributions in Prior Payroll and tax filings. Original I-551 Card Holders are recommended, depending on their given situation, to either apply for an I-90 Green Card renewal or apply for US Citizenship with the N-400 as to avoid issues that may arise in the next few decades (unknown how laws might change). What do I do if I need a new I-551 Green Card ASAP? By filing for either I-90 or N-400, USCIS may issue a "temporary I-551 proof" that can be in the form of the passport, a sticker on the card, or a stamp in an I-94 Card. This temporary proof is called an ADIT Stamp and can be acquired at a local USCIS Office in an INFOPASS Appointment. (More information can be seen here: https://www.fickeymartinezlaw.com/need-a-temporary-green-card-information-on-the-adit-stamp) The following is the SSA policy on ADIT Stamps: When the alien does not have a machine readable immigrant visa (see RM 10211.025C.2 ), DHS places a temporary I-551 stamp in the foreign passport as evidence of immigration status when the alien is admitted to the U.S. as an LAPR for the alien to use until the permanent I-551, Permanent Resident Card, is received. The stamp may be placed in the alien’s foreign passport or on a Form I-94, Arrival/Departure record, when the alien does not have a passport. When an alien previously admitted to the U.S. applies for a replacement I-551 or adjusts to LAPR status, DHS places a temporary I-551 stamp in the foreign passport. When the alien does not have a foreign passport, DHS places the temporary I-551 stamp, a photo of the alien, and DHS seal on Form I-94. Each stamp is uniquely numbered with a five-digit identifier which can be found below the “Valid Until” line. Also, the officer writes the “A” number on the stamp. See the ACM Alert No. 2006A-31 New DHS/USCIS ADIT Stamp under the “I-94” document number and “I-551” document number for more information on the design and fluorescent security features. (Source: https://secure.ssa.gov/poms.nsf/lnx/0200303440#b1)
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 14, 2025
The Blog Post will hopefully provide better guidance out there that may be nearly a decade old. The 319e Naturalization Option is available for: Green Card Holding Spouses; Whose spouse is an “Active Duty” Member of the U.S. Armed Forces (Not a Veteran or Independent Contractor); Who Currently Live Abroad on official Military Orders; and […] The post 319(e) Naturalization: Overseas Naturalization Option for Active-duty Military Spouses and Children appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 14, 2025
[Ler Post em Português] Under INA 319(b), Spouses of U.S. Citizens who are Employed or Stationed Abroad can be provided a new option for Naturalization. Normally, Spouses must hold their Green Card for a minimum of three years before being eligible to Naturalize through Marriage. Under INA 319(b), Spouses otherwise eligible for the 3-year Naturalization, […] The post INA 319(b) Naturalization Option: Spouses of U.S. Citizens Employed or Stationed Abroad appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 14, 2025
This guide is for the US Citizen that is trying to fully understand the US immigration consular process. You may have met an Italian online (possibly through EuroCupid/InternationalCupid) or after being stationed with the US Military abroad at: Aviano AFB Camp Darby Army Base Caserma Ederle Army Base Sigonella Navy Base Gaeta Navy Base La Maddalena Navy Base Naples Navy Base If you have an Italian Spouse or Fiance, this Guide will cover the most common topics and questions. First, what are the two Immigrant Visa Options: The CR-1/IR-1 Spousal (Immigrant) Visa, and The K-1 Fiance (Immigrant) Visa Second, how to get married in Italy? The US Embassy gives the following guidance for marrying in Italy: https://it.usembassy.gov/u-s-citizen-services/marriage/ However, a Virtual Marriage in Utah may also be a viable possibility. Meaning, the US Citizen and the Italian Citizen can be in different countries OR both can be in Italy, and the marriage ceremony can be held virtually in the state of Utah. More information can be seen here: https://www.utahcounty.gov/dept/clerk/marriage/marriagelicense.html Here are some common topics before we dive in to the process:
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 13, 2025
Many will talk about bring a Philippine Spouse to the US in many different ways: As a K1 Fiance As a CR1 Spouse As an IR1 Spouse As a K3 Spouse As an Immigrant Visa Holder The inherent issue with the Immigrant Visa process, is the processing time. However, what if there was a way to bring your spouse to the US quicker? What if they could be in the US in a matter of weeks or months? Shouldn't every option be considered? This Article will cover the alternative employment options that a Filipina/Filipino Fiance or Spouse could consider to "arriving" to the US quicker. The rule of Employment Visas, when you have a Fiance or Spouse in the US: Two requirements must be stressed: First, employment visas require employment to occur. You cannot come on an employment visa tomorrow, marry the day after, and then pursue a Green Card. That could be classed as visa fraud or circumventing immigration law. If you apply for the employment visa, you must work. Second, the employment should really be job history/education level appropriate. The employment can be used "in conjunction" with an immigrant visa process abroad in Manila. Additionally, there are very slim exceptions that may allow a Foreign Spouse to immigrate within the US through Adjustment of Status, versus Consular Processing. Possible Employment Visa Options based on some industry norms: Teaching/Education: J1 Cultural Exchange Teacher: A popular visa for teachers, where the interview process is facilitated through a J1 Sponsor, and a visa is acquired relatively quickly at the US Embassy in Manila. A list of J1 Sponsors can be seen here: https://j1visa.state.gov/participants/how-to-apply/sponsor-search/ The biggest consequence for the J1 Visa is the 2-year home residency requirement that restricts other employment visas such as H-1B until EITHER you've returned home to the Philippines for 2 years or you've acquired a J1 Waiver. R1 Religious/Private School Teacher: Requires a religious private school, such as a catholic school, to sponsor. More information on a Catholic School (Philippines is predominately Catholic) teaching position can be seen here: https://www.fickeymartinezlaw.com/deeper-dive-r-1-catholic-teacher-positions-how-to-locate-possible-religious-education-employment F1 Student utilizing OPT for Teaching Experience: A student visa holder may be able to acquire the ability to work (aka Employment authorization Card or Optional Practical Training) for 1 to 3 years (depending on whether education was STEM or Non-STEM). This teaching experience is very beneficial for acquiring a H-1B teaching position after the OPT Period. H-1B for Teachers: The most versatile teaching visa option, as many schools tend to have a relationship with a University or College to qualify for Cap-Exempt H-1B Status. More information on how to start can be seen here: https://www.fickeymartinezlaw.com/philippine-teacher-how-to-find-an-h-1b-position-in-the-united-states Healthcare/Medical Fields: H-1B for Medical Professionals and Nurses: Ideally, you should look for Hospitals/Clinics that have sponsored in the past. If they've done it in the past, they may be willing to sponsor again in the future. An unofficial (non-government website) list can be seen here: https://h1bgrader.com/job-titles/nurse-n60ezl4m0z/lca/2025 (You can limit the list by Specific Medical Position, by Year, and also by State) J-1 for Medical Professionals and Nurses: J-1 positions are also available, but the biggest consequence for the J1 Visa is the 2-year home residency requirement that restricts other employment visas such as H-1B until EITHER you've returned home to the Philippines for 2 years or you've acquired a J1 Waiver. Uneducated H-2B Professions: The Department of labor provides the following search bar to assist in locating possible H2b employment: https://seasonaljobs.dol.gov/jobs The common jobs (not an exhaustive list) are: Food Service & Hospitality: Line Cooks Servers Bartenders Housekeepers Front Desk Staff Dishwashers Construction & Labor: Construction Laborer Roofer Asphalt Worker Concrete Laborer Landscaper and Groundskeeper Amusement and Recreation Attendants Amusement Park Worker (very seasonal) Theme Park Worker (very seasonal) Meat, Poultry, and Fish Cutters and Trimmers: Chicken Processing Plant Worker Turkey Processing Plant Worker Pork Processing Plant Worker Crab Cannery Worker If someone has experience in the past with poultry, a chicken processing plant may be ideal. If they've worked in a factory, a cannery may be ideal. If the spouse has construction experience, construction may be ideal. The fact of the matter, there a numerous industries that are in need of employees. If a Foreign Fiance or Spouse can fill that employment position, why not consider the possibility. Disclaimer: This Blog is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.
By Franchesco Fickey Martinez May 12, 2025
This article will cover the topic of "How to find an H-1B Position?" The Teacher could be in the Philippines at this time, or could be in the US under an alternative teaching visa: J-1 Cultural Exchange Teacher R-1 Religious/Private School Teacher F-1 Student utilizing OPT for Teaching Experience First, lets cover the three visa categories that can bring a teacher to the US: J1 Cultural Exchange Teacher: A popular visa for teachers, where the interview process is facilitated through a J1 Sponsor, and a visa is acquired relatively quickly at the US Embassy in Manila. A list of J1 Sponsors can be seen here: https://j1visa.state.gov/participants/how-to-apply/sponsor-search/ The biggest consequence for the J1 Visa is the 2-year home residency requirement that restricts other employment visas such as H-1B until EITHER you've returned home to the Philippines for 2 years or you've acquired a J1 Waiver. R1 Religious/Private School Teacher: Requires a religious private school, such as a catholic school, to sponsor. More information on a Catholic School (Philippines is predominately Catholic) teaching position can be seen here: https://www.fickeymartinezlaw.com/deeper-dive-r-1-catholic-teacher-positions-how-to-locate-possible-religious-education-employment F1 Student utilizing OPT for Teaching Experience: A student visa holder may be able to acquire the ability to work (aka Employment authorization Card or Optional Practical Training) for 1 to 3 years (depending on whether education was STEM or Non-STEM). This teaching experience is very beneficial for acquiring a H-1B teaching position after the OPT Period. Second, What are some tasks every Philippine Teacher should Consider? Credential Education: Our clients have had positive experiences working with World Education Services , International Education Evaluations , and Education Credential Evaluators . However, the National Association of Credential Evaluation Services (NACES) provides a list of qualifying companies: https://www.naces.org/members . A helpful note, USCIS requires applicants to provide evidence of all degrees, certifications, or licenses received, including specifically: (1) Transcripts, (2) Diplomas, (3) Degrees, and (4) Certificates. Study for the TOEFL: Study for the Test of English as a Foreign Language. Recommend reviewing a free study guide or practice tests. Study for the PRAXIS: The Praxis exam tests the knowledge and skills needed to teach in a specific subject area and grade level. The testing requirements may vary on the state you plan to teach in as well as the grade level or subject area you are seeking to teach. Lastly, how can a Philippine Teacher locate an H-1B Position? Ideally, you should look for Schools that have sponsored in the past. If they've done it in the past, they may be willing to sponsor again in the future. An unofficial (non-government website) list can be seen here: https://h1bgrader.com/job-titles/teacher-g101183607/lca/2025 (You can limit the list by Specific Teaching Position, by Year, and also by State) This should be the starting point of Philippine Teachers planning to acquire an H-1B Teaching Position in the United States.
More Posts